Rohingya genocide case: What is Myanmar accused of at the ICJ?

The International Court of Justice is set to deliver a judgment on November 19  on a case that  The Gambia filed against Myanmar on November 11, 2019, accusing Myanmar of violating the 1948 Genocide Convention through atrocities against the Rohingya minority.

The application, submitted to the UN's principal judicial organ in The Hague, Netherlands, detailed allegations of mass killings, rape, sexual violence, destruction of villages and forced displacement of the Rohingya population in Myanmar's Rakhine State.

The following questions and answers explain the case, the allegations and the legal proceedings.

 Who are accused in the case?

Myanmar is the respondent in the case brought by The Gambia before the ICJ. The allegations concern acts committed by Myanmar's military, known as the Tatmadaw, and other security forces against the Rohingya population.

The Gambia is the applicant state. The alleged victims are members of the Rohingya minority, a predominantly Muslim community that has faced decades of discrimination and persecution in Myanmar.

The case is against the state of Myanmar, not individual military officers or political leaders. The ICJ deals with legal disputes between states and does not conduct criminal trials of individuals.

 What are the allegations against Myanmar?

The Gambia alleges that Myanmar committed acts of genocide against the Rohingya with the intention of destroying the group, in whole or in part.

The allegations include mass killings, rape and other forms of sexual violence, causing serious bodily and mental harm, deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group's physical destruction, and imposing measures intended to prevent births within the community.

The application also describes the burning and destruction of Rohingya villages, forced displacement and other forms of persecution.

The Gambia argues that these acts violated Myanmar's obligations under the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

When did the alleged atrocities take place?

According to the application, major military operations against the Rohingya took place in October 2016 and again in August 2017.

The August 2017 operations led to a massive exodus of Rohingya people from Myanmar into neighbouring Bangladesh. Hundreds of thousands fled across the border amid reports of killings, sexual violence and the destruction of their homes and villages.

The Gambia also referred to longstanding persecution and discrimination against the Rohingya before the military operations.

When did the case begin?

The Gambia formally instituted proceedings against Myanmar on November 11, 2019, by submitting an application to the ICJ.

The application was accompanied by a request for provisional measures, seeking urgent protection for the Rohingya population while the court examined the case.

Public hearings on the request took place from December 10 to 12, 2019, at the Peace Palace in The Hague.

Why did The Gambia file the case?

The Gambia argued that genocide was a matter of international concern and that all states party to the Genocide Convention had an obligation to prevent and punish it.

It relied, among other materials, on findings of the United Nations Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on Myanmar, which reported evidence of serious international crimes and called for accountability.

The Gambia maintained that Myanmar should be held responsible for its alleged violations of the Genocide Convention.

Which international law did The Gambia invoke?

The case was brought primarily under the 1948 Genocide Convention.

The Gambia relied on Article IX of the convention, which allows disputes between states concerning the interpretation, application or fulfilment of the convention to be brought before the ICJ.

It also referred to other provisions of the convention concerning the prevention and punishment of genocide, including Articles I, III, IV, V and VI.

What did The Gambia ask the ICJ to do?

The Gambia asked the court to declare that Myanmar had violated its obligations under the Genocide Convention and to order it to stop all acts that could constitute genocide.

It also sought orders requiring Myanmar to ensure that its military and other forces did not commit genocidal acts, prevent the destruction of evidence, protect the Rohingya population and fulfil its obligations to prevent and punish genocide.

The Gambia further sought appropriate reparations for the victims.

What was the ICJ's initial decision?

On January 23, 2020, the ICJ unanimously ordered provisional measures against Myanmar.

The court directed Myanmar to take all measures within its power to prevent acts prohibited under Article II of the Genocide Convention. It also ordered the country to ensure that its military and other forces under its control did not commit such acts.

Myanmar was further directed to prevent the destruction of evidence relating to the allegations and submit regular reports to the court on the measures taken to implement the order.

The decision was an interim measure intended to protect the rights of the Rohingya under the convention while the case proceeded. It was not a final ruling that Myanmar had committed genocide.

Was the case a criminal trial against Myanmar's military leaders?

No. The ICJ case concerns the international legal responsibility of Myanmar as a state, not the criminal liability of individual military officers or political leaders.The court can determine whether Myanmar violated its obligations under international law and can order appropriate remedies. It cannot convict individuals or impose prison sentences.

Individual criminal responsibility would have to be addressed through separate criminal proceedings before a court with the relevant jurisdiction.

Why is the case significant?

The case is significant because it is an effort by one state to hold another accountable for alleged genocide against a persecuted minority before the world's principal international court.

It also highlights the obligations of states under the Genocide Convention to prevent and punish genocide.

For the Rohingya, the proceedings represent an important international legal avenue for seeking recognition of the alleged atrocities, protection and accountability.

The case has also drawn attention to the international community's responsibility to respond to allegations of genocide and protect vulnerable populations.

What is Bangladesh's role in the case?

Bangladesh has played an important supporting role in the case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar at the International Court of Justice (ICJ). Although Bangladesh is not a party to the proceedings, it has provided diplomatic, technical and financial support to The Gambia.

Bangladesh has also shared information and documents relating to the Rohingya crisis and sent a delegation to The Hague to observe the hearings in December 2019.

Did Bangladesh provide financial support to The Gambia?

Yes. Bangladesh contributed $500,000 to the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation in November 2020 to support The Gambia's legal proceedings against Myanmar. The contribution was made towards the legal expenses of the case, which required substantial financial resources.

Why did The Gambia file the case instead of Bangladesh?

The Gambia took the initiative under a mandate from the OIC to pursue international legal action against Myanmar over alleged genocide against the Rohingya.

Bangladesh, which hosts more than a million Rohingya refugees who fled Myanmar, supported the initiative through the OIC rather than directly filing the case itself. This also allowed Dhaka to continue diplomatic engagement with Myanmar over the safe and voluntary repatriation of the refugees.

Who supported The Gambia in filing the case?

The principal institutional supporter was the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, which has 57 member states, including Bangladesh.

The OIC mandated The Gambia to lead efforts to bring the case against Myanmar before the ICJ at its 14th Islamic Summit in Makkah on May 31, 2019.

The Gambia subsequently filed the case on November 11, 2019.

Which countries provided financial assistance for the case?

Bangladesh, Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Nigeria were among the OIC member states that provided financial assistance to support The Gambia's legal proceedings. The OIC also called on other member states to provide voluntary contributions to meet the legal expenses.

Did the OIC itself file the case against Myanmar?

No. The case was filed by The Gambia in its own capacity as a state party to the Genocide Convention. The OIC provided the political and institutional backing for the initiative, while its member states, including Bangladesh, supported the legal effort through financial and diplomatic assistance.

News Courtesy:

https://www.newagebd.net/post/human-rights/322850/rohingya-genocide-case-what-is-myanmar-accused-of-at-the-icj